Jacopo da EMPOLI
(Florence 1551 - Florence 1640)
Glaucus and Scylla
Squared for transfer in black chalk, and with framing lines in brown ink.
Inscribed Hanibal Caracci and Caracci on the verso.
Further inscribed Anibal Caracci on a small label (part of a previous mount?) pasted onto the verso.
Numbered N3074. on the verso.
141 x 198 mm. (5 1/2 x 7 3/4 in.)
The subject of Glaucus and Scyllais taken from Greek mythology and Ovid’s Metamorphoses. Glaucus was a mortal fisherman who discovered a magical herb that brought the fish that he caught back to life. He decided to eat some of the herb, which made him immortal, but also caused him to grow fins and a fish’s tail, and forced him to live ever after in the sea. He became a sea-god and prophet, and came to the rescue of ships in storms. Glaucus fell in love with the beautiful nymph Scylla and wanted to marry her, but, repulsed by his piscine form, she fled onto land, where he could not follow.
The present sheet was first published by Antonio Vannugli in 1995. As he noted of the drawing, ‘The pose of Glaucus was altered in the final painting and the features of his face made more human; only the original satyr-like ears and fish tail were retained to refer to his identity as a sea-god…Empoli here drew with a continuous line that neatly defines the forms. Wash and white heightening were applied to convey a soft lighting that emphasizes volume. Such elements of style, derived from Pontormo’s and Bronzino’s draftsmanship, form the basis of Empoli’s “maniera soda” (or “firm manner”).’
In his discussion of the Sansepolcro Glaucus and Scyllain his monograph on Empoli, Marabottini proposed a date for the painting, on stylistic grounds, of c.1600. However, as Vannugli pointed out, the painting is perhaps more likely to date from a few years later, by virtue of a close stylistic comparison between this preparatory drawing and two other compositional studies by Empoli datable to the middle of the first decade of the 17th century. In technique and handling, the present sheet may be compared with an equally highly pictorial, squared drawing of The Madonna and Child with Saintsin the Uffizi, which is a study for a large altarpiece in the church of Santa Lucia dei Magnoli in Florence of c.1606-1607. Also comparable in style and technique is another drawing in the Uffizi, depicting The Assumption of the Virgin, which is thought to be a study for a now-lost painting, formerly in the Florentine church of San Michele Visdomini, of the early years of the 17th century. Like the two Uffizi drawings, the present sheet displays an animated and vigorous graphic manner, with an extensive use of white heightening and a freedom of penwork, which also reflects the influence of Pontormo.
Although the present sheet is the only known definitive preparatory study by Empoli for the painting of Glaucus and Scylla, Marco Chiarini had proposed that a red chalk study of the head of a young man by Empoli in the Uffizi may have been used for the head of Scylla in the painting. That drawing, while indeed very close in pose and appearance to the head of Scylla, is however more obviously related to that of a servant in Empoli’s painting of The Supper at Emmaus of c.1609, in the chapel of the Villa degli Albizzi (later Frescobaldi) at Pomino, outside Florence.
The present sheet was once part of the large collection of mostly Netherlandish drawings assembled by the Dutch collector Valerius Röver (1686-1739) of Delft. A manuscript inventory of the collection, in the University Library in Amsterdam, describes the present sheet, as a work by Annibale Carracci, under the inventory number 32./38: ‘[Portfolio] 32 [no.] 38: Zee God bij een zittend vrouwtje aan het strand root gewassen en gehoogt van dezelve 1-15’. (‘Sea God with a seated woman on the seashore washed in red and heightened by the same [ie. Carracci].’)
Röver’s collection of drawings, compiled into forty-two albums, was purchased en blocfrom his widow in 1761 by the dealer Hendrik de Leth for the sum of 20,500 florins, and was subsequently then acquired in its entirety by the Amsterdam banker Johann Goll van Franckenstein, the Elder (1722-1785). Born in Frankfurt, Goll van Franckenstein settled in Amsterdam around 1740. His collection is known to have numbered over a thousand drawings by 1759, even before his acquisition of the Röver albums. The collection passed in turn to his son, Johann Goll van Franckenstein, the Younger (1756-1821) and grandson Pieter Hendrik Goll von Franckenstein (1787-1832), before being dispersed at auction in Amsterdam in 1833, following the latter’s death. The sale of the Goll von Franckenstein collection, in which the drawings were divided into various albums, achieved an impressive total of 69,638 florins.
His widow, Cornelia Röver-van der Dussen, Delft
Purchased in January 1761 with the rest of the Röver collection by Hendrik de Leth, Amsterdam
Acquired from him by Jonkheer Johann Goll von Franckenstein, Amsterdam (Lugt 2987), with his number N3074. inscribed in red chalk on the verso
By descent to his son, also Johann Goll von Franckenstein, Amsterdam
His son, Pieter Hendrik Goll von Franckenstein, Amsterdam
Possibly the Goll von Franckenstein sale, Amsterdam, De Vries, Brondgeest, Engelberts and Roos, 1 July 1833 onwards
Eduardo Moratilla, Paris, until 1964
Bought from him by P. & D. Colnaghi, London, in June 1964
Acquired from them in 1967 by Egbert Haverkamp-Begemann, New York.